From "VII Russia" Cultural perfumes aesthetics of
France, Britain, Italy, the US. The differences you get.
Just after India, Turin drove down to Paris to the launch of the
perfumes he and John Stephen had created for Fragonard. The event
was to unfold on the seriously chic main level of Fragonard's Paris
office, 39 boulevard des Capucines, a spectacular 1930s theater
around the corner from Chanel's barracks on rue Cambon. Fragonard
was calling the fragrances the Absolus. Turin circled the block
a few times, found a place to park the blue Citroën, and showed
up to find things in full swing. He greeted Agnès Costa warmly
and shook hands with her mother, a handsome Frenchwoman wearing
a mink raincoat and diamonds. Everything bubbled like molten metal.
The lighting was Martian, and it intimidated.
There were a few different languages moving around the air, French
and English and something Russian-like and Italian, and Turin cocked
his head at them. "The French like luxury," he said, looking
thoughtful and sipping something, "but what the French call
luxury is actually call-girl chic. Put it this way. After finishing
secondary school in Milan at sixteen, I went back to Paris to go
to university, Paris XII, Pierre et Marie Curie. I rented a room
from Madame Clouzot, the sister of the film director Henri-Georges
Clouzot, right near the Champs Elysées. She explained that
there were only really two great French perfume makers. Guerlain
and Caron. Guerlain, she said, was for cocottes-kept women. Caron
was for the duchesse. But in fact it is 1880s cocotte style that
today passes for chic in France. What the French consider 'chic'
is actually a sort of kept-woman vulgarity." He looked very
grim, then permitted himself to pronounce "Hermès"
and then "Vuitton." "Caron, on the other hand,"
he said, brightening, "is absolutely proper, proper chic."
And what is that? He laughed, thought about it, said "um"
and "oh God." "Chic is, first, when you don't have
to prove you have money, either because you have a lot and it doesn't
matter or because you don't have any and it doesn't matter. Chic
is not aspirational." He sighed, despondent. "Chic is
the most impossible thing to define. Luxury is a humorless thing,
largely, and when humor happens in luxury it happens involuntarily.
Chic is all about humor. Which means chic is about intelligence.
And there has to be oddness-most luxury is conformist, and chic
cannot be. Chic must be polite and not incommode others, but within
that it can be as weird as it wants.
"The Italian perfume aesthetic is, of course, completely different.
What I call cashmere indigestion. They like floral Orientals, spice,
and flowers together, that sort of warm, uniform, suntanned beauty
with no chic whatsoever. Middle-class taste writ large. There's
a couple of really great Italian fragrances, mind you. Helietta
by Princess Helietta Caracciolo. I actually tracked her down at
her shop in Rome recently to ask her if she still had any of the
fragrance. She's a sweetheart. Orange-peel chypre with a woody angle.
And Teorema by Fendi. But in general, Italian perfumery-I essentially
look down on it. It's boring. Nothing is more nauseating than good
taste in high doses.
"The British have floral dresses, which are pale, and leathered
libraries, which are better. They've done some great masculines,
since Englishmen really do care. The dandy was an English creation.
Monogrammed-slippers-and-monocles like No. 89 by Floris or Lords
by Penhaligons. America is generally big and beautiful, the perfume
interpretation of the Hoover Dam. Americans are hygienic and athletic.
Cabochard-not the piss sold under the name today, the real stuff
that you can't get anymore-you have to be into soiled underwear
for that. It is a fucking wonderful fragrance. Not for Americans.
But having said this, Americans have done some really great fragrances.
Estée Lauder's Youth Dew, Aliage, White Linen. Among the
truly greats. Tommy Girl, which is quintessentially American and
one of the greatest twenty perfumes of all time. It was done by
Calice Becker. She's French. Actually, she's one hundred percent
Russian.
"Obviously, perfume culture itself is to a great degree gay
culture, though some people think you're not supposed to say it.
Gay guys were bored with all these stupid hairy-chested male fragrances
and went out and bought Alpona, by Caron, which is wonderful. Actually,
there aren't many gay perfumers. It's weird. Jean Guerlain said,
'I composed Chamade for my then girlfriend,' and I thought, 'Right.'
Turned out it was true. I mean, it's not weird in that the Grasse
milieu is still completely homophobic-I know one young guy who was
not taken in perfume school simply because he was gay. Mind you,
he was also a raging pain in the ass, but so what? The thing is,
all their customers are gay, and you'd think it would be to their
advantage to have a few around 'in house.' But instead they get
Englishmen. Fashion is gay. We're living under a gay dictatorship;
I'm sick of it. Look at that vile Gaultier's Le Male, what do I
care about that stuff? Put it this way: I love Old Spice-you go
back to the time of freshly shaven Daddy. What's wrong with that?"
At Fragonard candles incinerated fragrant molecules into the dark
electrical air. Powerful speakers at one-hundredth their capacity
were pumping a beat into the floor. The new four Absolus lined the
swank walls in oils and soaps and sprays, which the Fragonard employees-young
women like caryatids, slender as insects, sheathed in black-were
handing out to guests in immense shopping bags. The guests peered
inside, turning the bags this way and that.
Turin went back to the French. "If you consider Shalimar by
Guerlain, lovely, with a marvelous little black sillage, the trail
of perfume you leave behind you, Shalimar is nice the way the Paris
Opéra is nice, lots of plush velvet and gold. This is not
to say, by the way, that Guerlain hasn't done some chic perfumes.
Mitsouko is infinitely chic. But look at Tabac Blond by Caron. There's
something dykey and angular and dark and totally unpresentable about
that. It's a phenolic fragrance. If you bring the girl home and
she's wearing that, your mom's going to be alarmed. Unless your
mom's chic, in which case she'll say, 'I really like that girl who
wears Tabac Blond.' Tabac Blond is a woman smoking cigars and driving-not
being driven-way too fast."